Fireplaces are cozy focal points, functional heating systems, and sometimes even historic elements of a home. But if your fireplace is outdated, damaged, or isn’t getting used as much as you’d like, you might wonder whether you should repair or upgrade it.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right decision depends on what type of fireplace you have, the extent of the issues, and your budget. Let’s break down the things you should consider when making the best decision for your home.

Signs Your Fireplace Might Need Repairs

Sometimes a simple fix is all you need to get your fireplace back in tip-top shape. Here are a few signs that necessitate repairs instead of needing to upgrade or replace it.

• Cracked firebricks or panels: If you notice hairline cracks in the firebox or panels, it can often be repaired without replacing the whole system.
• Damper issues: A damper that won’t open or close properly can cause smoke problems and reduce efficiency. Damper repairs are pretty straightforward, and the way to go instead of a full upgrade or replacement.
• Minor chimney damage: Loose bricks or mortar joints, a damaged crown, or missing cap can usually be repaired without touching the fireplace itself.
• Draft problems: If smoke backs up into the house, it may be due to a blockage, an improperly sized flue, or negative pressure, all of which can be resolved with straightforward repairs.

If your fireplace still looks good and functions properly, aside from a minor issue or two, repairs are generally the more cost-effective and sensible option.

When It’s Time to Upgrade

Repairs won’t cut it in every situation. There are times when a full upgrade or replacement is the smarter move, especially if you want to improve your fireplace’s efficiency or update the look.

Here are the most common signs it’s time to upgrade.

• You rarely use it because it’s inefficient: Older wood-burning fireplaces are terribly inefficient, losing as much as 85% of the heat up the chimney. Upgrading to a gas insert or high-efficiency wood stove can make a huge difference in your comfort and energy usage.
• It doesn’t meet current safety codes: Building codes change over time. If your fireplace is decades old, it may not meet current safety standards, and upgrading may be the only safe option.
• Visible structural damage: Major cracks, shifting masonry, or water damage often mean the whole structure is compromised. In those cases, repairs can be just as costly as a replacement, without the benefits of a newer, more efficient unit.
• Aesthetic reasons: Let’s be honest, sometimes it’s all about looks. If your fireplace looks outdated or doesn’t match the rest of your home’s decor, an upgrade can dramatically improve the room’s appearance.

Weighing the Costs

Cost is typically the deciding factor for most homeowners. Small repairs can range from $150-$1,000, depending on the issue. Upgrades, especially if you’re switching fuel sources or installing an insert, can run several thousand dollars.

However, remember that a more efficient fireplace can save you money over time. Gas inserts, for example, can deliver zoned heating that reduces your reliance on central heat. And a modern fireplace may even boost the resale value of your home.

Questions to Ask Yourself

• Do I like how it looks?
• Is it safe and functional as-is?
• How often do I use it and for what purpose?
• Would an upgrade make it more enjoyable or efficient?

Fireplaces add functional style and charm to any home; however, they shouldn’t be a source of stress. Whether you want to repair your old fireplace or give it a makeover, you can rely on the pros at Keystone’s Fireplace and Stove.

We’ve been the most trusted fireplace, chimney, and stove experts in South Central, PA for over three decades. Whatever your fireplace needs, we can help. Call us today or visit our showroom located at 6621 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg, PA.